Mary Lou has taken it upon herself to play matchmaker for the remaining Fuller brothers, eager to see them all settle down. But her plans for Samuel, the quiet and thoughtful fifth brother, go awry when it becomes clear his heart is already set on someone. Samuel has admired her from afar for as long as he can remember, but his shyness has always held him back. Now, he knows if he doesn't act soon, he could lose his chance forever.
Just as he begins to gather his courage, a long-buried secret within the Fuller family starts to come to light. As the whispers spread through the community, Samuel fears the truth might ruin not only his chances of love but also his family's reputation.
Can Samuel overcome the obstacles in his path and find the love he's been longing for, or will the secrets of the past destroy his dreams?