After moving with her adoptive parents to the house at the end of the cul-de-sac, Summer York discovers there is more to Lightenborough Drive than she thought. "Fairy Tale" takes us alongside Summer as she dives into rumors about her street that swirl throughout Weston, Vermont. Summer learns about the "Devil House", immortal women, magical classmates, and secrets of where she came from buried beneath the blood of fairies and warlocks.

Once she realizes the magical truth of her past, Summer teams up with the warefae - fairy and warlock children who have been in exile for over a century - to unlock her powers and form enchanting relationships. As Summer establishes who she truly is, she must choose if she should sink back into the shadows, or risk her newfound immortality to fight for the freedom of her kind.